Product: Butterball Turkey Clear all filters (0 of 33 reviews match)
filters
Seller:
Show
State:
Show
City:
Show
Product:
The whole center of the breast was pink and raw. Had to toss it on thanksgiving. Butterball asked me for code, receipt or package which was all tossed out upon cooking. Can’t think of any item that I am about to eat that I keep the receipt. Very poorly handled and...
Read more
1.0
Product
Butterball Turkey
#1414446
Reply to reviews
I just bought Butterballs all natural Turkey Breast tenderloins a few hours ago. The package was sealed and the sell by date was Dec 7th. As soon as I took it out of the package to cook it, i almost fainted from the smell. It smelled ROTTEN. Never again
Read more
Anonymous
OutstandingMacaroniPenguin121

OMG, this story is ENDLESS!! Gone is the delicious Butterball Turkey that so many of us grew up with - and I mean REALLY gone, they were bought out some years back by Seaboard...

Product
Butterball Turkey
#1409375
Reply to reviews
I spent extra money per pound to get a Butterball turkey and am rather disappointed in the product. The 24.5 pound turkey was oily inside and out as I cleaned it. In fact, I had to wash my hands several times after cleaning the bird to get the oil off. This was unusual...
Read more
Product
Butterball Turkey
#1408397
Reply to reviews
As I prepared the 16 pound defrosted Butterball turkey for roasting I realized something was odd. It had no drumsticks and I could not find the neck inside the turkey. After 4 hours at 325 degrees, my daughter began to carve the turkey. She called to me from my...
Read more
Anonymous
Noel Korsu

I roasted my 19lb turkey for 4.5 he's, checked temp in 2 different places and it was 170 and it was bright pink inside. Put it back for another hour and still not fit to eat, ...

Product
Butterball Turkey
#1408237
Reply to reviews
Cooked turkey according to directions.Leaked about a half gallon of water after it was placed on platter while resting. Meat was rubbery and stringy. Tasted old.Tried it as left overs the next day but it was inedible. Threw it into the dumpster. Purchased it at Costco....
Read more
Anonymous
Jill T

Same here. Had very little meat and the dark meat was like shoe leather. Had to wrestle to get the legs off. Ended up putting most in the trash so we had no good leftovers. Ha...

1.0
Product
Butterball Turkey
#1406675
Reply to reviews
To begin-I want you to know that my family totally enjoyed our Butterball Thanksgiving Dinner this year. The turkey was so very delicious. The reason I wanted to write to you is because I had a couple of confusions during preparation of my Butterball. First-the cooking...
Read more
5.0
Product
Butterball Turkey
I liked
  • Flavor and appearance
I didn't like
  • Instruction confusion
#1406601
Reply to reviews
Show

Butterball - Very salty turkey breast

When I tried to cut the turkey it was too moist almost watery. It tasted salty not at all like turkey. I thought Butterball was a good brand. Will never buy it again.
Product
Butterball Turkey
#1406594
Reply to reviews
My husband purchased an organic butterball turkey from Costco this year. The packaging said fresh never frozen turkey. We bought it the Tuesday before Thanksgiving and thawing did not occur to me since it was supposedly never frozen. We opened the turkey and found it...
Read more
Product
Butterball Turkey
#1406556
Reply to reviews
I purchased a frozen Skinless Butterball Turkey Breast. For years I have made a rolled turkey breast with stuffing. The breast must be butterflied and pounded out to form a rectangle for rolling. This year to my surprise, when I opened the netted bag' It was a bunch of...
Read more
Product
Butterball Turkey
#1406550
Reply to reviews
Show

Butterball - Waterlogged turkey

I purchased a Butterball ready to roast turkey. I followed the instructions but it had a weird taste and was totally waterlogged. I threw it away. $20 down the drain.
1.2
Details
Billing Practices
Discounts and Special Offers
Diversity of Products or Services
Product or Service Quality
Value for money
Product
Butterball Turkey
#1406420
Reply to reviews